Open reviewing process
Encounters of life and scholarship: Opening to transformations, inquiries and vulnerabilities
David, Susanne, Dorian and Mohamed
Thank you for posting this revised version of your paper. I am happy that it meets the criteria and am recommending that it is accepted for publication.
Stephen's final comments: I enjoyed reading this latest draft. It makes better sense of some of the issues I raised. It would help your future work to get to know the literature I suggested earlier. I am uploading your text with marginal notes. My recommendation is conditional on your team working through the detail to produce your final draft
Dear Moira, Mark and Stephen,
Thank you so much for your thoughtful feedback. We have responded to all the suggestions made by Stephen - please see document attached.
We have found the open review process very helpful, thank you.
David, Susanne, Dorian and Mohamed.